Why doesn't it make sense to compare an entry-level DSLR with a super zoom?

Question

A friend of mine told me that it does not make any sense to compare a entry level DSLR (e.g. Nikon D5100) to a super zoom (e.g. Nikon Coolpix P510).

So, what does he mean by "it does not make any sense"?

Asked by Jack

Answer

Comparing feature-by-feature is meaningless, a DLSR (even entry level) and a superzoom point and shoot are systems that choose almost opposite tradeoffs at every important design decision.

It's a bit like comparing a sports car and a mini van - while both are cars they are different systems designed for different purposes.

If the words small, light or cheap are high in your priority list you have no reason to look at DSLRs.

On the other hand, if you want to control how your photo looks no P&S in a the world will give you the power and flexibility of a DSLR (especially after you add another lens or two and an external flash).

Answered by Nir

Check more discussion of this question.